How To Prevent Negligent Hiring and Retention Complaints

May 11, 2022

Employers can often be held legally responsible for their employees' actions, particularly while on the job. Claims of negligent hiring or retention can arise from coworkers, customers, or others who are harmed or put at risk by an employee. Common claims involve employees who may have violent criminal backgrounds, work while impaired, or who lack necessary knowledge or training to safely perform their duties.

What Is Negligent Hiring?

Negligent hiring is a legal term used in claims against an employer. Plaintiffs claiming negligent hiring indicate that employers knew or should have known an employee put others at risk, through incompetence or other characteristics, such as assault or theft. For example, if you fail to identify a candidate's history of violent behavior, and once hired, that person assaults a colleague, you may be held liable for negligent hiring.

What Is Negligent Retention?

Claims of negligent retention rely on the same principles—that an employer should have known an employee posed a risk. Unlike negligent hiring, which relates to an employer's choice to hire a risky individual, negligent retention relates to risks arising from a person who has already been hired. For example, if one of your employees is having aggressive, angry outbursts at work and you take no action, if that employee engages in a workplace shooting, you may be liable for negligent retention.

How To Reduce Your Risk of Negligent Hiring or Retention Claims

Employers obviously can't perform exhaustive investigations into each job candidate or employee, except for the most sensitive positions. They should, however, engage appropriate background screening services such as criminal background checks, credential verificationdrug screening, and driver's record screening, particularly for positions where employees may work without much supervision. Current employee behavior should also be observed, and questionable activity should be investigated and acted upon. Proactive and ongoing screenings followed by appropriate actions illustrate an employer's due diligence, and limit liability for negligent hiring and retention claims.


At Employers Reference Source, Inc., our background check expertise can help reduce your risk of negligent employment claims, and help you build a safe, effective workforce. Contact us today to learn more about our full suite of screening services.

Background Screening Compliance: What Does That Mean For Your Business?
21 Nov, 2022
Federal, state, and local laws work together to protect American workers from discriminatory employment practices. Read more about how you need to be in compliance when using background screening in hiring decisions.
California Senate Bill 1262 Vetoed: Background Check Delays Expected
11 Nov, 2022
California Governor Newsom recently vetoed a bill that would have allowed the return of birthdates and driver's license numbers as searchable fields in California court records. What does that mean for background checks?
Why Background Checks Matter in the Gig Economy
01 Nov, 2022
As an employer, hiring gig workers comes with changes to traditional hiring processes. While employment verifications (I-9s) aren't required for gig workers, job candidates must still be approved for hiring. Learn more about why background checks matter!
Employers: Continue Using Existing Form I-9 After October 31, 2022
19 Oct, 2022
The current version of Form I-9 is scheduled to expire on October 31, 2022 but because proposed changes have not yet been finalized, the USCIS just announced that employers should continue using the current form. An additional announcement will be made in the Federal Register indicating the new version is available.
Top 6 Things to Learn From Social Media Screenings
11 Oct, 2022
Social media screenings offer a valuable insight into both current and future employees. Let's look at six things you can learn from this service that complements traditional background checking options.
7 Common Questions About Drug Screening in the Workplace
01 Oct, 2022
It can be challenging to know where things stand on allowable drug screening processes. Here are answers to some common questions on the topic.
Is E-Verify Mandatory in Your State? | Employers Reference Source
22 Sep, 2022
Federal law requires the use of E-Verify for employers who are federal contractors or vendors. Currently, 22 states mandate E-Verify use for at least some employers and some categories of employees.
The Biggest Hiring Challenges in 2022 | Employers Reference Source
11 Sep, 2022
A recent survey conducted by Ogletree Deakins indicates what is probably no surprise to many employers — hiring and retention represent the biggest challenge employers currently face. While background checks won't necessarily make your employees more satisfied, they can make you more satisfied with your employees.
How’s the Latest Job Report Looking? | Employers Reference Source
01 Sep, 2022
Hiiring and retention represent the biggest challenge employers currently face. While background checks won't necessarily make your employees more satisfied, they can make you more satisfied with your employees.
Ban the Box: When Are Criminal Background Checks Legal? | Employers Reference Source
22 Aug, 2022
Criminal background checks can be an important part of ensuring worker and customer safety, as well as protecting your business and reducing your liability. Federal, state, and local laws, however, including "ban the box" legislation, restrict when and how that information can be gathered and when it can be used in relation to hiring and employment decisions.
More Posts
Share by: